An Obsessive People Pleaser Searches For Her Voice
At first, this blog was a secret. I only told a few people about it and, for a while, I wanted to keep it that way. It was scary enough to write honestly without worrying about who was reading it and what they would think the next time they saw me. But releasing the Crazy became a habit. I became frustrated with the effort it took to keep my stories straight. I was so full of the truth about me that I didn’t have any energy left to keep hiding. So I went public. I told my recovery group and a few friends. I told Jen she could link to me. I linked this page from my flickr site. I told my mom and then my mother-in-law.
I panicked.
I calmed down.
I rested in the very grown up idea that people’s reactions to what I wrote were their issue and that I wasn’t responsible for the way my story was interpreted as long as I told the truth. I understood that my job was to write honestly and candidly and let the chips fall where they will.
But what happens when my choice of words is unclear and sends waves of worry and concern throughout a community of people that love me? What happens when, in my attempt to connect to the shared human experience that makes the growing online community so amazing, I end up misrepresenting myself - again?
What does a writer do when she wants to be everything to everyone?
I try to avoid talking too much about church and my relationship with Christ on this blog for the very legitimate reason of not wanting to push my beliefs on people that might have different perspectives. I believe that as human beings, we have shared experiences that transcend religion and that any variety of people from different faiths can engage in conversation about the way our lives work, but this only works well when people don’t try to force their beliefs on others. I try, in life as well as on this blog, to let people know that I am a Christian and have a relationship with them that is open and genuine, trusting that if God wants me to act in some specific way towards them, He will let me know. And so I progress through life, figuring that as long as I am loving people and acting with compassion, God will work out the details. It works for me, allows me to sleep at night.
What I neglect to mention, sometimes, as a people-pleaser, is that I am a Christian. And as much as I may engage in the battle to break apart the American conception of Christianity, when I call myself a Christian, people use that as a reference point for their opinion of Christ and His followers. I forget that, in my quest to avoid being the person that passes out Bible tracts to the kids that come trick-or-treating; my life is still a reflection. I forget that this platform is public in a way that I can never fully grasp and that the people who read this might not get the whole picture.
I forget that it is easier to explain something in person than it is in print.
My recent posts about drunken blogging have caused some concern. The individual in me wants to dismiss those concerns by busting out my copy of the Bill of Rights and yelling something about individualism and the freedom of speech. I do believe in freedom of speech, but just because you are free to do something doesn’t mean you should. The fact is that words carelessly written or not well explained can cast an incomplete picture and leave people wondering what to think. They can reflect poorly on the beliefs and values that you claim to espouse. They can hurt your cause.
Let me explain further, I believe that the legalistic, Footloose-style Christianity of the Religious Right is wrong. I’m much more likely to quote Anne Lamott than James Dobson (in fact, I might start yelling if James Dobson comes up). I believe that Christ calls us to love and joy and freedom and love again. Because of this, I don’t have any problem with Sublime or Eminem coming up on my ipod. I won’t yell at you or walk away if you tell me that your beliefs or customs or ideas are different than mine, in fact, we’ll still be friends after the conversation. I’ll go to the club and dance. I’ll sit outside a coffee shop and talk gay rights or abortion while smoking a cigarette. And, yes, I will have a few drinks. And I believe that I can do all of these things and still honor Christ.
My error, in this case, was, I believe, in presentation. I didn’t focus on the redemptive and creative value of friendship and fellowship. I didn’t write about how having real, grown-up, friends has made me a better person. I should have written something different, something along the lines of: “Jen and I got together for some post-children’s-bedtime relaxing. We are talking, watching music videos and having a few cocktails. We are working on a hairbrush mix-tape….” Or I should have given you the back story of Meredith Vieira and the Today Show and explained the humor of two mom’s getting together for cocktails. I assumed that my readers would know my intent, a classic writer’s mistake. Instead, I glorified the idea of getting drunk with friends as the only way to have a good time. I wrote a quick post with the intention of soliciting suggestions for my hairbrush CD (thanks to those who have come so far, get yours in now if you haven’t already) and I assumed that my readers would shrug, laugh and dismiss the post. When I wrote it I wasn’t thinking about what it might do to people’s picture of Christians or of Christ. And for that I want to apologize. Because all though this is probably the preachy-est I will ever get, I want my life to reflect what I believe.
Those of us who are trying to follow Christ without locking ourselves away from the real world walk a fine line. Either we err by becoming legalistic - condemning, judging and censoring when we should be loving and helping. Or, we stray toward secularism, forgetting that, as believers, our lives should look different. It’s a constant tension and I don’t think anyone ever gets it right. But we keep trying.
So how does one reconcile the idea of having a public journal, detailing the good, bad and ugly parts of their life with the desire to not offend anyone? How do I continue to share my life with people that I would have otherwise never met, and in the process make the world just a little bit smaller, without diluting what I believe? How do I balance the knowledge that I have readers who are believers and those who aren’t? I have dear, dear friends on both sides of that line and I don’t want to ostracize anyone, yet in the process I end up offending Christ and diminishing the importance of my own beliefs. Why are my priorities backwards? Why am I not able to rest in the very grown up idea that people’s reactions to what I write are their issue, that I am not responsible for the way my story is interpreted as long as I tell the truth? When will I understood that my job is to write honestly and candidly and let the chips fall where they will?
This deep seeded desire for approval is the starting point for most of my lies. I spin this story so I appear to be a better mother. I rearrange these words to seem a better person, a cooler person. I omit a few key facts to complete the pretty picture of a nice girl who doesn’t have a whole bucket of Crazy floating around in her head. It doesn’t work. But I keep trying. I need to tell the story of my life. I need to recognize and validate my journey. I need to write and I need to know that people are reading what I write. For many of my readers this is the only way I communicate with them. The relationships that are built through blogging are important to me and I want to keep them intact. But if the point of this blog is working through my issues, I need to be true to myself and what I believe.
What I fail to realize is that, by its very nature, truth-telling is divisive. In trying to please everyone I will, as we know, please no one. So I am going to keep learning to tell the truth. I am going to keep writing, but I am also going to take a few more minutes to think before I hit that notorious publish button. One of my best friends always signs her notes “To thine own self be true”. And I am going to take her advice. I am going to continue walking the steps of my journey, as a human being, a daughter, a woman, a wife, a mother, a Christian, and I hope to find connections with people on at least one of those levels and I will trust that we can work on the relationship from there.
I have agonized over this essay. I have re-written and re-worded almost everything in here and if you struggle with something I have said I ask you to come and talk to me about it. This is me. This is my story. Thank you for coming along.
Posted by Jenny on February 26th, 2007 in Untangled Webs | 7 Comments










